We Haven’t Got Time!” | HR Mistakes UK Employers Make | Consensus HR – Herts & Beds
“We Haven’t Got Time!”
The HR excuses that come back to haunt employers
Consensus HR | Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire & Cambridgeshire
“We haven’t got time.” “They know they’re not performing.” “We’ll do the paperwork later.” Sound familiar?
Over the next three Thursdays, Consensus HR is looking at some of the most common excuses we hear when businesses have not completed essential HR processes — and, more importantly, what can happen when an apparently small shortcut turns into a much bigger people problem.
It is about making sure employees know what is expected, managers know how to manage and the business can demonstrate what it has done if a situation later becomes disputed.
Excuse 1: “We Haven’t Got Time to Complete the Probation Review”
Our answer: Make time.
If your business has invested time and money recruiting somebody, their probationary period should be actively managed. Probation should not consist of putting a date in the diary for three or six months’ time and hoping everything goes well.
Managers should discuss performance, conduct, attendance, training, objectives and any areas requiring improvement throughout probation. If there is a problem, tell the employee, give clear examples, explain what improvement is required, offer appropriate support and set a review date.
Problems may continue until the end of probation, leaving the employee able to say: “Nobody ever told me there was a problem.” Employers should also remain mindful of contractual obligations and legal risks including discrimination and automatically unfair dismissal protections.
Manage probation from day one — not on the final day.
Excuse 2: “They Know They’re Not Performing — I’ve Told Them Loads of Times”
Our answer: What does your documentation show?
Managers frequently tell us that they have spoken to an employee “loads of times”. We then ask: When? What was discussed? What examples were given? What improvement was required? Was a timescale agreed? Was support or training offered? When was it going to be reviewed?
Not every management conversation needs to become a formal HR process. Informal conversations are an extremely important management tool. But important conversations should be appropriately documented.
Months later, the employee may remember events differently. Instead of clear evidence of repeated discussions, the position can become “I definitely told them” versus “No, you didn’t.” A simple contemporaneous note or follow-up email can make the position considerably clearer.
If the conversation matters, appropriately record it.
Excuse 3: “We’ll Sort the Paperwork Out Later”
Our answer: Later has an unfortunate habit of becoming never.
Employment documentation is not simply administration. Written records provide clarity about what has been agreed and can help prevent misunderstandings later.
This can apply to probation, performance, sickness absence, flexible working, reasonable adjustments, disciplinary and grievance matters, training and changes to employment arrangements. Records containing personal information must also be handled appropriately under applicable data-protection requirements.
Managers leave. Employees leave. Memories fade. Circumstances change. Six months later somebody asks, “What did we actually agree?” — and nobody can prove the answer.
Comment from Matthew Chilcott — Owner, Consensus HR
Probation is a perfect example. Don’t recruit somebody, leave them largely unmanaged for three or six months and then suddenly decide at the end that they are not suitable. Manage from day one. Talk regularly. Set clear expectations. Document the important points and deal with concerns when they arise.
Twenty minutes spent managing something properly today could save hours, days or even weeks further down the line.”
Matthew Chilcott — Owner, FCIPD, ACEL, BA (Hons)
Next Thursday…
Part Two: “But We’re Only a Small Business!” We tackle three more familiar excuses, including why being an SME does not mean employment law can simply be ignored — and why “everyone knows the rules” can be a dangerous assumption.
Need practical HR support?
Consensus HR supports SMEs across Hertfordshire, Bedfordshire and Cambridgeshire with practical, proactive HR and Employment Law support.
Telephone: 01438 576750
Email: [email protected]
Website: www.consensushr.com
Latest HR blogs: consensushr.com/blogs-hr/
